UPREIT vs. DownREIT: Key Differences and Which Path May Fit
Both UPREITs and DownREITs allow you to contribute real estate to a REIT-controlled partnership in exchange for partnership units and generally defer capital gains tax under IRC Section 721. The key distinction lies in where your property is held. In an UPREIT, your property joins the REIT’s single operating partnership, which holds substantially all of the REIT’s portfolio. In a DownREIT, it is placed into a separate partnership that typically holds only your property or a small number of properties.
This structural difference affects what your units are tied to, how your terms are set, and how you eventually exit. UPREITs are the more widely used structure and are the foundation of DST-to-721 exchange programs. For a detailed look at how the contribution process works, see our guide to UPREITs and 721 exchanges.
Key Takeaways
Both UPREITs and DownREITs can defer capital gains tax on contributed property. Redeeming your units, or the partnership’s sale of the property, can trigger the deferred tax liability.
UPREIT units generally track the REIT’s entire portfolio. DownREIT terms are negotiated deal by deal and may be tied to the performance of a specific property.
UPREITs have been the more widely used structure since the early 1990s, and their unit terms tend to be more standardized across unitholders.
Neither structure suits every investor. Liquidity, control, concentration risk, and your individual tax profile all warrant careful consideration. Review the offering documents and consult a qualified tax advisor before proceeding.
This article provides a general overview of the two structures. It does not offer guidance on a specific deal or program. Terms vary from deal to deal, and tax rules change, so review all offering documents and agreements carefully. Use this overview as a starting point, and consult your tax professional about how a particular transaction would apply to your situation.
What Is an UPREIT? (Real Estate Investment Trust)
An umbrella partnership real estate investment trust (UPREIT) holds substantially all of its properties through a single operating partnership (OP). The REIT parent entity may be publicly traded or private. When you contribute a property to an UPREIT, you receive operating partnership units in that OP. These units can typically be redeemed for cash or REIT shares after a required lockout period.
What Is a DownREIT?
A DownREIT is a REIT that owns properties directly while also forming one or more separate partnerships — each typically holding a single property or a small group of properties — to acquire real estate from owners in exchange for partnership units.
This structure gives REITs that are not organized as UPREITs a way to offer sellers a potentially tax-deferred exit. Without it, those REITs would generally be limited to taxable purchases, which trigger capital gains tax for the seller.
A DownREIT transaction follows three steps:
The REIT forms, or already controls, a property-level partnership — typically serving as general partner or managing member.
You contribute your property to that partnership.
You receive partnership units. A negotiated partnership agreement sets the distribution, redemption, and lockout terms, and it accounts for the economic and tax implications for all parties.
The partnership holds the property, and the REIT controls the partnership. Your units represent an interest in that single property, not a share of the REIT’s full portfolio.
UPREIT vs. DownREIT: Key Differences
The distinction comes down to what your units represent. In an UPREIT, your units reflect an interest in the REIT’s single operating partnership — and by extension, its entire portfolio. In a DownREIT, your units are tied to a separate, property-level partnership, and depending on the agreement, your exposure may be narrower.
UPREIT
DownREIT
Where contributed property goes
The REIT’s single operating partnership
A separate partnership alongside the REIT’s directly owned assets
What units generally track
The REIT’s full portfolio
Varies by agreement; may be tied to the contributed property or pegged to REIT dividends
Diversification
Generally broader than a DownREIT, spanning the REIT’s portfolio
Often concentrated in one property or a small group
Terms
Generally standardized across unitholders
Negotiated deal by deal
Redemption
Typically for cash or REIT shares after a lockout period
Typically for cash or REIT shares, on negotiated terms
Tax-structuring complexity
Moderate
Higher, because of property-specific economics
How common
The more widely used structure since the early 1990s
Less common; used mainly by REITs not structured as UPREITs
Available through DST-to-721 programs
Yes, in programs that include a 721 option
Generally not
The most relevant distinction is the second row. In an UPREIT, the value of your units — and any distributions they pay — moves with the REIT’s entire portfolio, so your outcome is less dependent on any single property. In a DownREIT, it depends on the agreement. Your distributions may be tied to how your specific property performs, or they may be pegged to the REIT’s dividend. When they’re tied to the property, that cuts both ways: you retain more of its upside, but you also bear more of its risk.
Which Is Better: an UPREIT or a DownREIT?
Neither structure is universally superior. If you are seeking portfolio-wide diversification, standardized terms, and a potential path from a 1031 exchange, an UPREIT may be the better fit. A DownREIT may be appropriate if you own a single large asset that a specific REIT wants to acquire and you have the leverage to negotiate property-specific terms.
Where an UPREIT Tends to Fit
You want to step away from day-to-day property management. The REIT’s operating partnership handles leasing, maintenance, and operations, so you hold OP units as a passive investor (as with a DownREIT).
You want exposure to a more diversified portfolio rather than a single asset.
You prefer standardized unit terms that apply uniformly across all unitholders.
You are completing a 1031 exchange and want a potential path into a REIT later, through a Delaware Statutory Trust (DST) that includes a 721 option.
You are planning your estate and want interests that can be divided among heirs more easily than a whole property — with the option, depending on agreement terms and timing, to later convert those units into REIT shares.
Trade-Offs to Consider With an UPREIT
You relinquish control over when the underlying property is sold.
Your units generally have limited liquidity. The partnership agreement governs redemption rights, and restrictions apply. Whether the REIT is publicly traded or non-traded affects your liquidity after redemption, and if you redeem into non-traded REIT shares, you may still hold an illiquid investment.
Redeeming units for cash or REIT shares is generally a taxable event. Consult a tax advisor before redeeming or converting units, as the timing and method of redemption can materially affect your after-tax outcome.
Once you hold OP units, a further 1031 exchange is generally no longer available, because partnership interests are not like-kind real property.
Distributions are determined by the REIT and are not guaranteed.
Where a DownREIT May Fit
You want to step away from day-to-day property management. The REIT’s operating partnership handles leasing, maintenance, and operations, so you hold OP units as a passive investor (as with an UPREIT).
You own a large, stabilized property that a particular REIT is actively seeking.
You are positioned to negotiate lockout periods, redemption terms, and tax protections directly with the acquiring REIT.
Trade-Offs to Consider With a DownREIT
Your returns may be concentrated in a single property, meaning its performance can drive your outcome more than a diversified portfolio would.
Distribution, redemption, and lockout terms are negotiated deal by deal, which typically requires additional legal and tax review before you contribute.
Property-specific arrangements draw closer scrutiny under the disguised-sale and partnership anti-abuse rules. An agreement that is not carefully structured may put tax deferral at risk.
Fewer REITs use this structure, which can limit the pool of potential buyers for your property.
As with an UPREIT, you give up control over when the property is sold, redeeming units is generally a taxable event, and distributions are not guaranteed.
Can You Choose Between Them?
Typically not from the same buyer. In most cases, the structure is determined by the acquiring REIT and the terms of the transaction. Some REITs operate under both structures, though not every deal will offer both as an option.
Before committing to either, review the partnership agreement and offering documents with your tax advisor and legal counsel.
Why Are UPREITs More Common Than DownREITs?
UPREITs are more common because their structure is simpler, whereas DownREITs involve greater complexity. A single operating partnership is easier for a REIT’s business to manage and administer and easier for you to evaluate. A DownREIT requires a separate partnership — and often a separately negotiated agreement — for each property it acquires. The UPREIT became the dominant structure for new REITs beginning in the early 1990s. DownREITs emerged primarily as a workaround for REITs organized under different structures, allowing them to compete for property owners seeking to defer capital gains taxes.
Three structural factors explain the preference:
One partnership, one set of terms: Every UPREIT unitholder holds an interest in the same operating partnership, generally on the same terms. A DownREIT may maintain several partnerships, each governed by its own agreement.
Clearer valuation: OP units are generally redeemable for REIT shares or their cash equivalent, so their value is tied to the REIT’s share price, or for non-traded REITs, its published share value. DownREIT units tied to a single property are harder to value independently.
Simpler tax administration: The REIT tracks built-in gain and any tax protection commitments within one partnership rather than across each separate entity and the related compliance burden.
These same structural advantages are why DST-to-721 exchange programs are built on the UPREIT model.
Is an UPREIT or a DownREIT More Liquid?
Both structures involve limited liquidity, so you should be prepared to hold your investment for an extended period. How liquid your investment is depends largely on whether the REIT is publicly traded and on the risk factors disclosed in the offering documents.
In both structures, your interest remains illiquid until your units are redeemed. UPREIT operating partnership units typically include redemption provisions but may impose a lockout period. DownREIT redemption terms are negotiated deal by deal and may be more restrictive. In either case, redemption is generally a taxable event.
The end of a lockout period does not guarantee redemption. Requests may be limited, delayed, or suspended. If you receive non-traded REIT shares instead of cash, you may hold an illiquid investment, and a secondary market for those shares may not exist. Review the partnership agreement and offering documents with your tax advisor before you invest.
How Taxes Compare in UPREIT and DownREIT Contributions
Both structures rely on the same foundational rule. Under Section 721 of the Internal Revenue Code, you generally recognize no gain or loss when you contribute property to a partnership in exchange for a partnership interest. IRS Publication 541, Partnerships covers this rule and each of the exceptions below. The tax is deferred, not eliminated, while you hold your units. Under current law, a stepped-up basis at death may reduce or eliminate it for your heirs.
The same core exceptions apply to both structures:
Disguised sales: If you contribute property and receive cash or other consideration from the partnership within two years, the transfers are presumed to be a sale under Treasury Regulation § 1.707-3 unless the facts clearly indicate otherwise.
Debt relief: If you contribute mortgaged property and your share of that debt decreases, the reduction is treated as a cash distribution and can trigger taxable gain if it exceeds your tax basis.
Built-in gain: Under Section 704(c), any gain that existed at the time of contribution is allocated back to you if the partnership later sells the property.
Investment-company rule: Section 721 deferral does not apply to a partnership treated as an investment company — generally relevant to contributions of diversified securities rather than real estate.
Where the two structures differ is in the level of scrutiny they attract. Because DownREIT units carry negotiated distribution and redemption terms, which may be pegged to the REIT’s dividend rather than the partnership’s own results, disguised-sale and partnership anti-abuse analyses tend to carry greater weight. DownREIT agreements generally require more careful structuring to preserve deferral.
In either structure, redeeming your units generally triggers the deferred tax. Consult your tax advisor before contributing property, as individual circumstances vary.
FAQs
In most cases, no. A REIT’s existing structure determines which option it offers, so your decision typically comes down to which REIT to work with or which path to pursue. If you are coming from a 1031 exchange, DST-to-721 programs are built on the UPREIT structure.
DST-to-721 programs are generally structured as contributions to an UPREIT’s operating partnership, not a DownREIT. Whether and when a DST’s property is contributed is at the REIT’s discretion and is outlined in the offering documents.
Generally, yes. Both rely on Section 721 and are subject to the same exceptions, including the disguised-sale rules and gain from debt relief. However, DownREITs typically require more careful structuring to preserve deferral, given their negotiated, property-specific terms. Consult your tax advisor.
Under current law, heirs generally receive a stepped-up basis in inherited partnership units, which may reduce or eliminate the deferred gain for income tax purposes. Units can also be divided among heirs more easily than a whole property. Estate and tax situations vary — consult your tax advisor and estate planning attorney.
Load More
Explore UPREIT and 721 Exchange Opportunities With 1031 Crowdfunding
If you are looking to step away from active property management while deferring capital gains tax, 1031 Crowdfunding offers two paths toward an UPREIT.
Contribute Your Property Directly
Our 721 exchange program works with a REIT that acquires larger multifamily, senior housing, and student housing properties. The process follows three steps:
Apply: Submit your property for underwriting to determine eligibility.
Contribute: Transfer your eligible property to the REIT’s operating partnership through a 721 exchange.
Own: Receive OP units in exchange for your contributed property.
If you are completing a 1031 exchange, 1031 Crowdfunding also offers DSTs that include a 721 exchange option. A DST interest generally qualifies as like-kind replacement property, and the REIT may subsequently acquire the DST’s property in exchange for OP units. This option is exercised at the REIT’s sole discretion and is not guaranteed.
On either path, eligibility is subject to underwriting and offering terms. Once a 721 exchange is complete, a further 1031 exchange is generally no longer available. Register for a free investor account to review current offerings, and a representative will follow up to assist you in meeting your investment objectives.
This material should not be construed as tax advice, and you should consult with your tax advisor, as individual tax situations will vary. This is provided for informational purposes only and does not constitute an offer to sell or a solicitation of an offer to buy any security. Any such offer may be made only by means of the applicable Private Placement Memorandum (“PPM”) or prospectus, which contains important information regarding the investment objectives, risks, fees, expenses, and other material terms of the offering. As with all investing, investing in private placements is speculative in nature and involves a degree of risk, including loss of your principal. Past performance is not necessarily indicative of future results, forward-looking statements and projections are not guaranteed to achieve the results described, and your actual returns may vary significantly. Investments in private placements are illiquid in nature, and there may be no secondary market or ability to sell the investment should the need for liquidity arise. Securities offered through Capulent, LLC, member FINRA, SIPC.
Get Our Free eBook!
Sign up for our newsletter and receive a free copy of our eBook.